image of judges

Judges' Blog

30 weeks of reading - Episode 1

Wednesday 19.03.08 12:00am
By: Louise Doughty

Deadlines are there to be broken.  All writers know that.  My favourite quote about deadlines is from the writer Douglas Adams, notorious for virtually faxing his books to his publisher page by page while the printing presses stood ready and waiting.  ‘I like deadlines,'  he reputedly said,  ‘I like listening to the whooshing sound they make as they fly past.

When you judge the Man Booker Prize, the deadline is inexorable.  On Tuesday 14th October, we have to make an informed choice, having read all the entries.  Like most people with freelance careers, I'm a big fan of advance planning.  There's nothing I enjoy more than flicking through my diary and making notes in it about how many weeks of the year are left - putting lines through the ones when my kids are on their school holidays, writing ‘NOVEL????' in the ones when I think I might be able to get some work done on my book.  After I've done that, I feel like I've almost done the work already and it's time for a coffee.  So this morning, I leafed through the fancy red moleskine that a friend gave me for Christmas, and worked out that, school holidays included, I have just over 30 weeks of judging the prize.  Oodles of time, I thought.  Then I thought about the (roughly) 120 books we will have to judge.  Even my rudimentary maths skills can work out that's four books a week.  Except we don't have 30 weeks to read them all because the longlist meeting is in July, which means... at this point, I stopped doing the maths. I had come over a little faint.

Up until now, it's been a breeze.  As our chair of judges said in his blog, there are certain books we already know will be entered - previous winners and anyone who has been shortlisted in the last ten years - so (with apologies for the mixed metaphor) a few big guns are already under our belts.  In addition, other entries have started to trickle in, mostly from the small presses who seem to be the only publishers with the good sense to enter books early.  This has created the illusion that trickling is what the entries will do, whearas once the official deadline for entries is passed, the trickle will turn into a flood. I look forward to the whooshing sound

Despite some nervousness as this date (April 1st) approaches, we seem to be a pretty cheerful bunch.  We had a very pleasant dinner before Christmas.  We joked along with each other nicely at the judges' photocall in January.  ‘You must be very pleased we all get on so well,'  I said to Michael.  ‘Ask me again in October,'  he replied. 

Posted in: Man Booker Prize 2008
Wednesday 19.03.08 01:19pm
calveni commented:

Could you perhaps explain how a book gets a fair reading when there is so many?

Wednesday 19.03.08 04:00pm
Moe commented:

Congratulations on your first post.

You mentioned there are certain books that you already know will be entered because of their standing (previously nominated/shortlisted etc). Doesn't this kind of limit the possibility of talented new authors being explored if you only have so many slots to fill? Perhaps I'm confusing your explanation. It just doesn't sound fair.

Wednesday 19.03.08 06:36pm
Lrushdi commented:

Hi Louise, thanks for the post. I look forward to reading about your reading. :)

You mentioned having to read 120 books in all. Do all the judges have to read ALL the entries? I somehow was under the impression that each of the judges read a selection of the books and choose a few of them for everyone to read. Would not this reduce the workload and also let you focus more and therefore do more justice to the books you read?

Tuesday 01.04.08 10:39am
IonTrewinAdministrator commented:

Hi Moe, Louise will be posting up more news shortly but just in response to your question –this system in fact widens the list of possibly authors each year. Each publisher is only allowed to submit two books each year. If the prize didn’t allow previous winners and shortlisted authors to be automatically entered then the publishers would be likely to choose previously successful authors over first time novelists to use within their quota. So each year the net is cast wider….

Tuesday 01.04.08 10:41am
IonTrewinAdministrator commented:

Hi Lrushdi, Louise will be writing more in her blog soon but in the meantime I can respond to your question. Some literary prizes do operate a system where not all the judges read all the entries in order to reduce the workload. The Man Booker Prize however asks its judging panel to read and consider every single novel submitted. Any novel too quickly dismissed by a judge might be picked up on by others on the panel, which means that at longlist stage none of the submissions slips through the net. The prize believes that this systems gives more novels a chance with the judging panel.

Tuesday 01.04.08 10:42am
IonTrewinAdministrator commented:

Hi calveni, Louise will be blogging again soon but I’ve just responded to another blogger (Lrushdi) on a similar question and hope that this gives you a response in the interim.

Saturday 02.08.08 12:05am
Panther1 commented:

My question is simple enough and it is a geniuine question.

Is the Booker a genuine competition? If it is, there are many baffled people, like me, who wonder why some very good books are not included. (If you need an example, "Breath" by Tim Winton)

Panther

Tuesday 09.09.08 03:52pm
Poppy commented:

Panther, as Ion Trewin commented, above, each publisher is only allowed to enter 2 titles, so your question as to why Tim Winton's "Breath" was not entered (assuming he wasn't, and you're not simply gripeing about why he's not on the long list - in which case, shame on you) should be directed to his publisher, Picador.

Picador has a good track record of Man Booker winners and longlisted & shortlisted authors (eg. John Banville), so they would be the best judge of which books to enter from their stable of authors.

And, believe it or not, some authors refuse to allow their book to be entered....

Add a comment

Do you have an account? If so log in here to comment.

Please note: The account username and password for commenting on the blogs is the exact same as the username and password required to comment in the forum. If you are already registered with the forum but cannot remember your password please contact moderator@themanbookerprize.com.

Don't have an account? Sign up today.

No account? Sign up for an account

The Man Booker Prize Fiction at its finest